This Just In: Everyone Disagrees!
MTV provides links to positive, negative, and strongly negative reviews of Watchmen.
Bob the Angry Flower’s creator Steve Notley has a review worth reading in the commentary for his March 6th cartoon, which sadly won’t be on the front page forever. I don’t agree with his negative conclusions, but I second his general statements about the sex and violence. I do have a higher opinion of the sex scene than he does. The music was kinda awkward, I’ll grant him that.
Rotten Tomatoes currently gives the movie a 65% rating. Their collection of reviews is certainly worth reading. There were several that I thought were spot-on.